Skip to content
Find a starting point

Blog / Follow-up

Follow-up

Your seller leads went quiet. Here's the 90-day follow-up that brings them back.

Most sellers are not ready on the first call. The ones who sell are usually the ones you kept talking to.

A seller who says “not yet” has not said no. They are early, busy, scared or waiting on something. Most investors call once or twice, hear “let me think about it,” and move on to the next lead. The seller who would have sold in month three never hears from you again.

Below is a 90-day follow-up plan you can copy, with sample timing and sample messages. The plan is simple. The hard part is running it every week while you are also closing deals.

Why most sellers are not ready on the first call

A first call is rarely the day they decide.

Selling a house is a big decision. Many sellers on your list did not wake up planning to sell. Someone inherited a house through probate and is still sorting things out with family. An owner is behind on property taxes and hoping to catch up. A landlord got a code violation letter and is deciding whether to fix it or walk away. A homeowner in pre-foreclosure may be waiting on an answer from the bank. Most are also talking to an agent, a relative or two other investors.

So your first call is often the first time anyone asked. “Not yet” is a timing answer. Your job is to be the person they remember when the timing changes.

What a 90-day follow-up schedule looks like

A sample cadence. It is an example, not a rule. Adjust it to your market.

Example 90-day follow-up for a seller who said not yet. Sample only.
DayChannelPurpose
Day 1TextThank them for the talk. No pressure.
Day 3TextOne easy question: did you get a chance to think it over?
Day 7Call and voicemailPut your voice in their phone.
Day 14EmailShort note: how a sale would work, what you can do on their timeline.
Day 30TextAsk if anything changed with the house.
Day 45CallCheck in. Listen for a new reason to sell.
Day 60Text and emailRemind them you are still buying in their area.
Day 90TextLast note for now. Door stays open. Move them to a slower list.

Spread the touches out, mix texts, calls and email, and stop when they tell you to. A seller who replies moves to your active list the same day.

What to say

Short, plain and human. These are sample messages. Put them in your own voice.

Day 1 text (example): “Hi Maria, this is Dan. Thanks for talking today. No pressure on the house. If you have any questions, text me anytime.”

Day 3 text (example): “Hi Maria, Dan again. Did you get a chance to think it over? Happy to answer anything, even if the answer is no.”

Day 30 text (example): “Hi Maria, checking in. Has anything changed with the house since we talked?”

Day 60 text (example): “Hi Maria, I'm still buying in your area and I can close on your timeline. Want me to put a number together, no strings?”

Day 90 text (example): “Hi Maria, last note from me for now. If you ever want to talk about the house, my number is the same. Take care.”

Three rules. Use their name and one detail from your last call. Ask one question. Never guilt them for going quiet.

Why it does not happen when you are closing

Follow-up is the first thing to slip.

When a deal is closing, that deal gets your day. The seller who said “call me in a month” gets nothing, because nothing breaks when you skip them. No one complains. The lead just sits in the CRM, and the half-built drip you meant to finish stays half built.

Mayek Real Estate had the same problem. Good leads sat untouched in the CRM while the team was busy closing. Follow-up needs an owner whose job it is, every week, not a plan you mean to get to.

Instant reply and offer follow-up

Two moments where the clock matters most.

Instant reply. When a new seller fills out your form or texts in, they should hear back within a minute, by text and email, in your voice. A missed call should get a text back right away. A seller who hears back fast is far more likely to stay in the conversation than one who waits a day.

Offer follow-up. After you send an offer, silence is normal and easy to ignore. A short note a couple of days later, another a week after that, and a call to ask what is holding them back can bring back offers that would otherwise fade out. Many sellers who say yes later are the ones who got a second or third touch.

Who should run it

You. This works if your list is short and you protect time for it. It stops working the week you have three closings.

A VA. This works if you will train, check and manage them. Some investors do well with it.

Someone who sets it up and helps run it. That is what I do for real estate investors, inside the CRM you already use, with approval points we agree on first. See the Mayek Real Estate case study for an example.

Want help with follow-up?

The first call is free. Tell me how your follow-up works today. Find a starting point